Skip to main content

Born This Way

Science, Citizenship, and Inequality in the American LGBTQ+ Movement

Born This Way

Science, Citizenship, and Inequality in the American LGBTQ+ Movement

The story of how a biologically driven understanding of gender and sexuality became central to US LGBTQ+ political and legal advocacy.

Across protests and courtrooms, LGBTQ+ advocates argue that sexual and gender identities are innate. Oppositely, conservatives incite panic over “groomers” and a contagious “gender ideology” that corrupts susceptible children. Yet, as this debate rages on, the history of what first compelled the hunt for homosexuality’s biological origin story may hold answers for the queer rights movement’s future.

Born This Way tells the story of how a biologically based understanding of gender and sexuality became central to LGBTQ+ advocacy. Starting in the 1950s, activists sought out mental health experts to combat the pathologizing of homosexuality. As Joanna Wuest shows, these relationships were forged in subsequent decades alongside two broader, concurrent developments: the rise of an interest-group model of rights advocacy and an explosion of biogenetic and bio-based psychological research. The result is essential reading to fully understand LGBTQ+ activism today and how clashes over science remain crucial to equal rights struggles.


304 pages | 6 x 9 | © 2023

Gay and Lesbian Studies

Gender and Sexuality

History of Science

Law and Legal Studies: Law and Society

Political Science: American Government and Politics

Reviews

“Today, the belief that LGBTQ+ people were ‘born that way’ is widespread, and generally taken as indisputable truth. Joanna Wuest traces the history of beliefs about the origins of ‘homosexuality,’ later expanded to include the entire LGBTQ+ spectrum in a meticulously referenced and nuanced story. This book would make an excellent choice for university classes on social movements, LGBTQ+ studies, sexuality and the law, or anyone interested in the rise of biological explanations for complex human behaviors. . . .a valuable contribution to LGBTQ+ research and activism and should be required reading for those engaged in advocacy work in the current political climate.”

Journal of Homosexuality

“Wuest marshals impressive empirical evidence and tells a detailed story of the relationship between the LGBTQ+ movement, law and science. . . .Born this Way is an impressive achievement that sheds new light on a vital and timely topic.”

Law & Society Review

“Wuest argues that beyond the catchy slogans one can trace an ideology that has subsumed LGBT activism, politics, law, science, and healthcare since the 1950s. Genetic or prenatal determinism has been the major arrow in the activist’s quiver, readily adjusted to counter the arguments of anti-gay conservatives. In Wuest’s critique, sexual determinism became a tenet of faith in the LGBT corridors of power early on, leading to gay normalization that neutralized activists’ erstwhile radical queer agenda. She convincingly shows that every stakeholder in the LGBT movement has channeled some version of ‘Born This Way.’ Even the anti-establishment purists seeking to topple essentialist categories in favor of flexible identities are shown to be entangled with remnants of determinism.”

Gay & Lesbian Review

Table of Contents

Introduction

Part 1 Origins
1 The Science of Civil Rights: The Rise and Demise of Sexual Deviancy
2 Desire in the Throes of Power: Gay Liberation, Psychiatry, and the Politics of Classification 
3 “Why Is My Child Gay?”: The Liberal Foundations of Born This Way 
4 Immutability before the Gay Gene: Biology and Civil Rights Litigation 

Part 2 Evolutions and Adaptations
5 Rise of the Gay Gene: Science, Law, Culture, and Hype 
6 From Pathology to “Born Perfect”: Marriage Equality and Conversion Therapy Bans
7 The Scientific Gaze in Transgender and Bisexual Politics 
Conclusion: Beyond Born This Way: Fluid Desires, Fixed Identities, and Entrenched Inequalities

Acknowledgments 
Notes 
Index 

Awards

Society for Social Studies of Science: Rachel Carson Prize
Honorable Mention

Be the first to know

Get the latest updates on new releases, special offers, and media highlights when you subscribe to our email lists!

Sign up here for updates about the Press